The Mid-Year Pivot: What to Change in January, Decided in November

by | Nov 3, 2026 | Implementation Gap, Leadership | 0 comments

Share This Story

November 3, 2026 · 5 minute read

The short answer:

mid year instructional planning has a deadline nobody announces: the leaders who execute a sharp January reset made their decisions in November, before the holiday stretch swallowed the calendar. The work is four honest questions about the fall (what moved, what was actually implemented, where the minutes leaked, and what deserves more) followed by the Keep, Cut, Intensify calls, written down, with owners. Decide in November and January executes a plan. Defer to January and you will make the same decisions cold, three teaching weeks later, with the window that much narrower.

Here is a calendar truth I learned the hard way as a principal: January does not plan. January executes, or January flails, and which one you get was settled back in November. The weeks between now and winter break are the last stretch of the year with enough daylight to read your fall honestly and change course on purpose. This is the month the strong leaders quietly do their most important thinking, and the four questions below are how our partner leaders do it.

Question one: what does the data say actually moved?

Not impressions, movement: BOY to now, on progress monitoring and any mid-fall checks. Which intervention groups moved at their 6 to 8 week reviews, which flat-lined, which grades grew? Write three sentences of fact before any interpretation, the same discipline as the data meeting, applied to the semester.

Question two: what did we actually implement?

The gentlest, most important question of the four. The August plan said daily warm-ups, coaching cycles, weekly data meetings; the honest November question is which of those happened at full dosage and which happened on the days nothing interfered. No blame attaches, because the answer is almost never about effort; it is about what the system protected. You cannot evaluate a plan you only partly ran, and knowing which parts ran is the difference between cutting a strategy and cutting a dosage problem.

Question three: where did the minutes leak?

Pull the master schedule you built in July and walk it against reality: the assemblies, the coverage emergencies, the pull-outs that crept into the protected block. Every leak you name now is a rule you can write before January, which is when the schedule stops being a document and becomes the strategy again.

Question four: what is working that deserves more?

Somewhere in your building, something outperformed the plan: a teacher whose groups keep graduating, a warm-up routine that spread on its own, a coaching pairing that caught fire. The pivot is not only repair; it is investment, and the fall’s quiet winner is usually starving at sixty percent of the dosage it has earned. Torgesen (2004) reminds us the window narrows every month, which cuts both ways: it is also the argument for feeding what is verifiably working, now, rather than in a spring review.

January does not plan. January executes what November decided, or improvises what November deferred.

Then make the three calls

Keep, Cut, Intensify: every initiative, routine, and commitment goes in exactly one column, on evidence, in writing, with an owner and a January start date. It is the simplest exercise we run with leadership teams and reliably the most clarifying hour of their year.

FAQ

When should schools plan their January instructional reset?

In November, before the holiday stretch compresses the calendar. Leaders who read the fall and write their Keep, Cut, Intensify decisions in November execute a ready plan in January; leaders who defer make the same decisions cold, weeks later, with less of the year left to benefit.

What four questions read the fall honestly?

What does the data say actually moved; what did we implement at full dosage versus partially; where did protected minutes leak from the schedule; and what is quietly working that deserves more investment. Facts first, then the decisions.

What is the Keep, Cut, Intensify framework?

A one-hour leadership exercise: every initiative and commitment is placed in exactly one column on evidence. Keep what is working at current dosage, cut what evidence cannot defend (with dignity and thanks), and intensify the proven winner that is running below the dosage it has earned.

 

About the author: Dr. Chandra Williams, Ed.D., is the founder and CEO of the Center for Student Achievement Solutions. A career educator who spent eight years as a school principal, she leads CSAS’s partnerships with schools and districts nationwide, including a multi-year Brooklyn partnership where all eleven partner schools improved for three consecutive years. Her team delivers structured literacy coaching, MTSS and reading intervention systems, and literacy leadership development, built on one conviction: educators do not need another vendor. They need a partner in the building.

References: Torgesen, J. K. (2004), Avoiding the Devastating Downward Spiral. District results verified against Acadience Reading source data.