November 5, 2026 · 5 minute read
|
The short answer: the school district professional development budget gets written in quiet November drafts, months before anyone votes on it, so November is when a superintendent’s three questions do their work: What share of our professional learning spend funds transfer (coaching) rather than exposure (workshops)? What are we sunsetting, so every line defends itself with evidence rather than tenure? And what does each literacy line actually buy, measured in changed classrooms rather than seats filled? Ask them now, while the draft is soft, and January’s budget tells the story you chose. |
Budget season has a public phase and a real phase. The public phase is the spring vote; the real phase is happening right now, in November spreadsheets where line items quietly roll forward because they existed last year. A superintendent who shows up to the real phase with three questions shapes the year more in an afternoon than the whole public phase will allow. Here they are, with the evidence that gives each one its teeth.
Question one: what share of PD funds transfer, not exposure?
Ask your business office to split the professional learning budget into two piles: exposure (workshops, conference seats, one-time sessions) and transfer (sustained, in-classroom coaching). Most cabinets have never seen the split, and it usually explains the results. The research is blunt about which pile works: Joyce and Showers (2002) found training alone transfers to practice for only a small fraction of teachers while adding coaching lifts implementation to roughly 95 percent, Kraft, Blazar, and Hogan’s meta-analysis (2018) found coaching among the strongest effects ever measured for professional learning, and TNTP’s The Mirage (2015) documented districts spending nearly 18,000 dollars per teacher per year the other way, with no evident practice change. The question is not whether to spend; it is which pile the next dollar joins, and the full case for the reallocation is here.
Question two: what are we sunsetting?
A budget where nothing ever ends is a budget where focus goes to die. Bring the Keep, Cut, Intensify discipline to the line items: every initiative defends itself with student evidence or honest leading indicators, and the ones that survive on loyalty get a dignified sunset, with thanks, so their minutes and dollars can feed what is working. Pair this question with your principals’ November pivot work and the building-level and district-level decisions reinforce each other instead of colliding in February.
Question three: what does each literacy line buy, in changed classrooms?
Reframe the unit of purchase. A line that buys 400 workshop seats sounds efficient until you price it per classroom that actually changed; a coaching line prices honestly because the leading indicators are countable: cycles delivered, decisions logged, groups moved, minutes protected. Ask every provider, including us, the same three vendor questions: what is the dosage, who does the work, and what transfer evidence will leaders see in classrooms by a named date. Providers with real models answer gladly.
|
Budgets are the one document where a district’s beliefs and its behaviors are forced to agree. |
The instrument that answers all three
The District Literacy Audit walks the same four domains these questions live in, instruction, professional learning, schedules, and leadership, with evidence prompts your cabinet can complete before a single line is drafted. And if you reported three things to your board in September, this is where the credibility pays: you enter budget season as the leader whose fall promises are visibly being kept, asking questions the evidence has already answered. That position is what closing the implementation gap looks like at the district line-item level.
FAQ
What literacy questions belong in budget season?
Three: the split of professional learning spend between transfer (coaching) and exposure (workshops), the sunset list that makes every line defend itself with evidence, and the cost of each literacy line measured in changed classrooms rather than seats filled. All three belong in November, while drafts are still soft.
How much of a PD budget should fund coaching?
There is no universal percentage, but the direction is settled: research from Joyce and Showers through the Kraft, Blazar, and Hogan meta-analysis shows coaching is where practice actually changes, so every training line should carry a funded coaching plan, and reallocation toward sustained cycles buys more change per dollar than additional workshop seats.
What should sunset to keep the plan focused?
Any initiative that cannot defend its line with student outcome evidence or honest leading indicators. Sunset it with dignity and thanks, then move its dollars and minutes to the proven work running below full dosage. A budget where nothing ends is a plan where nothing is protected.
Get the District Literacy Audit, free.The 12 questions across instruction, professional learning, schedules, and leadership, with evidence prompts and scoring, built for exactly this month’s cabinet table. |
About the author: Dr. Chandra Williams, Ed.D., is the founder and CEO of the Center for Student Achievement Solutions. A career educator who spent eight years as a school principal, she leads CSAS’s partnerships with schools and districts nationwide, including a multi-year Brooklyn partnership where all eleven partner schools improved for three consecutive years. Her team delivers structured literacy coaching, MTSS and reading intervention systems, and literacy leadership development, built on one conviction: educators do not need another vendor. They need a partner in the building.
References: Joyce, B., and Showers, B. (2002), Student Achievement Through Staff Development, 3rd ed. Kraft, M. A., Blazar, D., and Hogan, D. (2018), The Effect of Teacher Coaching on Instruction and Achievement, Review of Educational Research. TNTP (2015), The Mirage. District results verified against Acadience Reading source data.

