Before You Sign That Curriculum Contract: 7 Questions Superintendents Ask Too Late

by | Jul 21, 2026 | Implementation Gap, Leadership | 0 comments

Share This Story

July 21, 2026  ·  6 minute read

The short answer:

The best curriculum adoption questions are not about the curriculum. They are about the system it lands in: what the audit found, where the coaching budget lives, which minutes the schedule protects, what decision rules the data will follow, what current initiatives sunset, what Year 2 costs, and what evidence of transfer you will accept by November. Ask all seven before signing and the adoption succeeds on purpose; ask them in October and you will answer them at three times the price.

Summer is contract season, and somewhere on your desk sits a literacy curriculum agreement with a number on it that made the board inhale. Here is the counsel I give every superintendent who asks, offered as a former principal who inherited three adoptions and led one: the purchase is the easy part, and the questions below are the whole game. Good partners answer them gladly; the answers tell you whether you are buying a curriculum or an outcome.

1. What problem did our audit say we have? If the honest answer is that no audit happened, pause the pen. In most struggling adoptions we review, the materials were adequate and the system around them was not. Buying before diagnosing is how districts purchase solutions to problems they do not have. Thirty days of honest auditing costs a fraction of one stalled adoption.

2. Where is the coaching line in this budget? Joyce and Showers (2002) found that training alone transfers to classroom practice for only a small fraction of teachers, while training paired with in-classroom coaching reaches roughly 95 percent. TNTP’s The Mirage (2015) found districts spending nearly 18,000 dollars per teacher per year on development with no clear practice change to show for it. If the contract funds materials and workshops but not sustained coaching, you are buying the two ingredients the research says are not sufficient.

3. Which minutes will the master schedule protect? A curriculum needs a home in time. Before signing, name the daily foundational skills block in every early-grade classroom and confirm the schedule protects it against every competing claim. Materials without minutes become shelf inventory.

4. What decision rules will our data follow? The new program will generate assessments. Decide now what each one will change, who decides, and by when, or the data will arrive and simply be admired.

5. What are we retiring to make room? Every adoption should come with a sunset list. Initiatives that survive on loyalty rather than evidence will quietly compete with the new work for minutes, attention, and belief. Keep, cut, or intensify, in writing, before launch.

6. What does Year 2 cost when the launch energy fades? Ask for the support model after the kickoff year: coaching days, refresher training for new hires, and who answers the phone in month 14. Sustainable adoptions are priced for the plateau, not just the honeymoon.

7. What will transfer look like by November? Agree on the evidence in advance: what leaders will see in classrooms, on which look-fors, by which walkthrough dates. An adoption without a November checkpoint is a purchase order with hopes attached.

Why you rarely hear these questions from vendors

There is no villain here, just an incentive: companies that sell products are structured to answer product questions. The seven above are system questions, and they are exactly where the implementation gap lives. It is also why our full implementation checklist for district leaders spends one domain on materials and three on everything around them. In the Brooklyn district where all eleven partner schools improved for three straight years, the curriculum barely changed. The seven answers did.

Bring the contract. We will bring the questions.

A thirty-minute strategy call before you sign: we will walk the seven questions against your actual plan and tell you plainly what is strong and what needs a line item. If you do not need us after that, we will say so.

Subscribe to The Click →

FAQ

What should districts ask before buying a reading curriculum?

Seven system questions: what the audit found, where the coaching budget lives, which minutes the schedule protects, what decision rules the data will follow, what sunsets to make room, what Year 2 support costs, and what evidence of classroom transfer leaders will accept by November.

Why do curriculum adoptions stall?

Rarely because of the materials. Adoptions stall when training arrives without coaching, schedules never protect the minutes, data never drives decisions, and old initiatives keep competing for attention. The research is consistent that transfer, not content, is the failure point.

What matters more than the curriculum purchase?

The system around it: sustained coaching, a protective master schedule, written data decision rules, and leaders who can see the practice in classrooms. Districts that fund those four turn adequate materials into verified growth.

About the author: Dr. Chandra Williams, Ed.D., is the founder and CEO of the Center for Student Achievement Solutions. A career educator who spent eight years as a school principal, she leads CSAS’s partnerships with schools and districts nationwide, including a multi-year Brooklyn partnership where all eleven partner schools improved for three consecutive years. Her team delivers structured literacy coaching, MTSS and reading intervention systems, and literacy leadership development, built on one conviction: educators do not need another vendor. They need a partner in the building.

References: Joyce, B., and Showers, B. (2002), Student Achievement Through Staff Development, 3rd ed. TNTP (2015), The Mirage. District results verified against Acadience Reading source data.